Tag Archives: Estate

NOW: NOTICE OF CLASS ACTION SETTLEMENT FOR VIOXX

Merck's Super Aspirin

9 Years after the recall of the drug Vioxx some of the Canadian victims will be compensated by a class action settlement.

 

VIOXX CLASS ACTION SETTLEMENT CANADA NOW BEING IMPLEMENTED. FILING CLAIMS OPENED APRIL 20, 2013

THE COURTS OF ALL PROVINCES APPROVED THE VIOXX SETTLEMENT FOR ENFORCEMENT AND NOTICE HAS BEEN PUBLISHED  THAT WE WILL BE ABLE TO SUBMIT CLAIMS TO THE CLAIMS ADMINISTRATOR FROM SATURDAY APRIL 20 TO MONDAY AUGUST 19, 2013.  NOTICE WAS PUBLISHED IN MAJOR NEWSPAPERS ACROSS CANADA ON SATURDAY APRIL 20TH. THIS FOLLOWS THE MAIN SETTLEMENT APPROVALS WHICH TOOK PLACE IN 2012.  DETAILS ARE AS FOLLOWS:

In the summer of 2012 a settlement of Vioxx injury claims in Canada was presented for approval to courts in Ontario, Saskatchewan and then Quebec.  The courts were asked by lawyers for Merck and lawyers for the class action to approve a settlement that was negotiated in 2011 and announced in January 2012. For background information, settlement details and events leading up to settlement approval please read our earlier posts.

The courts were asked to either accept or reject the negotiated agreement and also approve the fees and expenses to be paid from the settlement to the consortium of law firms across Canada who were involved in the class action proceedings.  There was no jurisdiction to change the terms of settlement.  In a decision released September 18, 2012 Madam Justice Leitch of Ontario’s Superior Court of Justice approved the settlement and approved the fees, taxes and disbursements of the class action lawyers.  A similar approval decision was issued by Justice Marcotte of the Quebec Superior Court on October 4, 2012. Justice Currie of the Saskatchewan Court of the Queens Bench also gave approval but without issuing reasons on July 25, 2012.

The settlement as approved provides for the following payments to be made by the drug manufacturer Merck:

1.  $3,500,000 to be paid to Canada’s provincial health insurers to reimburse medical expenses of Vioxx victims.

2.  $1,000,000 to be paid for the cost of notices and claims administration.

3.  $6,000,000 to be paid to the class action lawyers allocated as approximately $4,500,000 for legal fees, $1,000,000 for expenses and $500,000 for GST and provincial taxes applicable to the legal fees.  This does not include any money for the lawyers representing individual claimants who will be paid from the money available to pay actual claims of Vioxx victims.

4.  $22,612,500 to be paid to Vioxx victims who are eligible for payment under the settlement.  That amount will be increased if there are over 1,500 such people to a maximum of $26,381,250. Most claimants will pay their own lawyers a percentage of their recovery for legal fees, taxes and expenses none of which are provided for in the settlement.

To be eligible for payment under the settlement a person must pass both the “usage gate” and the “event gate”.  The usage gate requires a certain amount of Vioxx to be consumed in the time immediately before the event.  The event gate requires a person claiming to have had a heart attack, sudden cardiac death or an ischemic stroke.  Stroke victims will be given $5,000 compensation regardless of the severity of the stroke or its lasting effects.  It is estimated for those with heart attack or sudden cardiac death, that after deductions for various risk factors (other than Vioxx use) and after legal costs the average person will receive $15,000 to $25,000 compensation.  That means some will receive more  and some will receive less.  The maximum in the best case would be about $100,000 before legal fees.  There is also payment to spouses and children (including adult children) of victims which is additional money up to 20% of what is paid to the principal claimant.  In every case certain medical and pharmacy records are required to prove use, show other risk factors and prove that there is a qualifying event.  The cost of obtaining records is an expense that is to be paid from the compensation received. As well most claimants will pay from the compensation legal fees averaging one third of the compensation paid.  They will also pay provincial and federal tax (PST, HST, GST) on the legal fees.  There is no income tax payable on the net compensation that victims and their families will actually receive.

The compensation being paid to Vioxx victims is clearly quite low in relation to the seriousness of having had a heart attack, stroke or sudden cardiac death.  The court considered that these events are common in Canada among persons who have not used Vioxx and that use of Vioxx is not necessarily the cause of the event.  They considered expert medical opinion on Vioxx’s role in causation noting that the connection to stroke is not as clearly proven as the connection to heart attack.  They accepted that persons with other conditions not covered by the settlement were a minority in the class and that it was reasonable and in the best interests of the class as a whole to accept a settlement that did not compensate them. The courts considered the continuing denial by Merck of any liability and the risk of the case not succeeding if the settlement was not approved.  They did consider the negative result in the Australian court and the fact that cases tried in the US had mixed results.  It was noted that even if the case proceeded to trial successfully payment of claims could be delayed by appeals. The court decided that the settlement is in the best interests of the class members.

The approval decisions had to be confirmed for enforcement purposes in the courts of all other Provinces.  This had to be completed before any claims for Vioxx victims can be submitted for processing to the class action administrator.  The Miskin law office is now submitting Vioxx claims for processing and payment.  We have been in contact with the class action administrators who will be receiving claims for compensation and processing them.  On April 20th there will be national advertising of the settlement and the claims processing will then begin. We are sending claim forms to clients to sign and also have signed by family members who are eligible for compensation.  This was expected to happen some time in January 2013 but due to delays in Provincial enforcement approval it took until March to get all the Provincial court orders and we now know that April 20 is the first day to begin to submit claims for processing. There is a period of four months open for submission of claims. At the end of that period assessment notices will be sent out by the claims administrator for every claim filed and payment of Canadian Vioxx claims will finally begin. If you believe you have a claim and have a lawyer make sure they have everything they need to file the claim.  If you do not yet have a lawyer you really should get one immediately to ensure you have everything you need in time to make a claim. Our office is still accepting new clients who qualify under the settlement but it is necessary to fully document claims which makes it difficult if you have not started to document a claim. It is essential to move quickly to have sufficient information in time to file a successful claim.

Power of Attorney or Will: Be sure to Meet Legal Requirements

gavel on will

It is important to plan well for your Will and get personalized legal and sometimes accounting advice first.

Wills, Power of Attorney and estate planning are matters to be taken very seriously.  The Miskin Law Office prepares Wills and Power of Attorney for individuals in Ontario, Canada. This is done after a first meeting with a lawyer and the client to assess a client’s situation and needs in order to prepare the best document to meet the individual requirements and decision making wishes of the client.  The purpose is to use estate planning to simplify future estate issues to ensure a smooth transition of assets which will reduce the need for future legal services and also plan for reducing taxes payable after death.  We encourage clients to prepare wills that do not lead to family disputes which can ruin relationships and cost a lot of money.  Where there already is an estate dispute we work with clients to resolve the issues sensibly and avoid costly court proceedings.  If there is a dispute mediation is a big part of our law firm’s range of services and we represent clients in Estate Mediation. Murray Miskin also acts as mediator in estate disputes. Estate litigation can be very costly and time consuming and we usually refer complex or unresolvable disputes to lawyers who specialize in such litigation. We are willing to mediate these disputes but we will no longer act for a party litigating these disputes. The best thing is to avoid disputes with estate planning and properly prepared legal documents. A Will is a document that you can sign with your binding instructions as to who will receive your assets after your death. It names an Estate Trustee (formerly known as Executor) whose responsibility after your death is to manage the estate in accordance with your wishes. You may also propose guardians for your underage children and indicate preferred funeral arrangements in your will. We often prepare specialized wills for people who have children with disabilities or special needs. Until your death the will may be revoked or changed so long as you are mentally competent. Minor changes can be done by Codicils which cost less than a new will. Wills should be redone immediately on a marriage break up. If you do not have a valid will the legal requirements of the law determine what happens to your estate without consideration of your preferences.  This may be fine for many families where there are no second marriages, common law relationships, specific bequests or unusual preferences to be considered.  If you are living common law or there are children of prior relationships involved it would be wise to obtain legal advice immediately.

A Power of Attorney for property is a document you can sign which gives power only in your lifetime over your assets to another person whom you may designate. That authority may be set up to be effective any time or only if you become incapacitated. It may be restricted to dealing with or not dealing with certain matters. You may have more than one person designated so both or either may sign for you. You may name alternates and specify whether the attorney has a right to be paid for what they do. It does not take away your own rights to sign on your own behalf.   A Power of Attorney for Property which our office refers to as POA,  is a critical document to have should you ever become totally incapacitated or suffer a loss of mental competence.  A Power of Attorney expires on your death.

You may also sign a separate  Power of Attorney for Personal Care where you authorize another person  (again with an alternate) to make health care choices for you when you are unable to do so yourself. This is sometimes called a Living Will. In it you may state your preferences on treatment issues and life support questions.  Many people who want these documents prepared have strong opinions on the possible choices their doctors and family members will have should they become sick to the point where they may have no hope of recovery and may become a burden on others.  Some people do not want their next of kin to decide what to do but instead they may have  a close friend or other relative they wish to involve in decisions.  You may also name a doctor or type of doctor you wish to have assess you and give advice when critical decisions must be made.

We strongly emphasize the need to use a lawyer to prepare any of the above documents to ensure it is valid and does what you want it to do.  Cheap Will and Power Attorney kits are available but pose a serious danger, in that, what you prepare will be invalid unless properly done following strict legal requirements.   For the money you save doing it by yourself it is not worth the risk.  In preparing these documents we always have a lawyer meet with you for as long as necessary to advise you and take careful instructions to make sure the document prepared is what you want it to be. We generally bill and expect full or partial payment by cash or cheque at the first meeting.  It is important to have a fully qualified and experienced lawyer discuss your intentions with you to ensure that the will is done properly.  We do not believe it is sufficient to give instructions to a member of the lawyer’s staff in a meeting, by letter or email, or by phone.  It is important that the lawyer use their judgment to assess capacity issues at a meeting to prevent future disputes of wills. We sometimes require clients to get a doctor’s note on capacity ahead of signing a will. At a later meeting the documents are signed in accordance with Ontario legal requirements with the lawyer present to oversee, explain the document and discuss any last minute changes.  In cases of complicated wills with unusual provisions or special requirements due to personal circumstances we may charge extra and we will let you know and decide how to proceed at our no cost or obligation meeting in advance of actual will preparation.

Our usual fees (including basic planning for the estate and including disbursements) are set out below with 13% HST added to any fee: Wills: one will $300, a pair for $500
Codicils (Will Changes): fee for one is $125, $200 for a pair
Power of Attorney (POA): one document of each type is $200, a pair of each type are $300.  These fees are USUALLY discounted when multiple documents are prepared.  Typically you will save $50 or more per person by preparing a Will with a Power of Attorney or both types of Power of Attorney. Call for exact price details for your situation. Documents requiring unusual clauses and extra planning may cost more as well.

WHERE NECESSARY WE WILL TRAVEL OUTSIDE OF OUR OFFICES AND IN THOSE INSTANCES OUR USUAL HOURLY RATES FOR EXTRA TIME AND ANY MAJOR DISBURSEMENTS WILL APPLY TO CLIENT ACCOUNTS.

The above fees are discounted when multiple documents are prepared.  Clients pay the fee on a first meeting to discuss wills and then the documents are reviewed and signed on a second visit.  We usually  store the original signed Will and give clients 2 copies. For Powers of Attorney we usually make 3 originals and the client keeps 2 and we hold the 3rd. We keep original documents in our heavy fire proof filing cabinet at our office until they are needed or signed out by the client.  WE ENCOURAGE YOU TO GET YOUR WILL DONE SOON. NOBODY KNOWS WHEN THEIR WILL IS GOING TO BE NEEDED OR WHEN THEY MAY LOSE CAPACITY TO SIGN A WILL OR POWER OF ATTORNEY.

Some clients require personalized estate planning for their special situations. In some situations it is advisable to have more than one Will.   We may refer you to accountants or other experts to help with planning. This will cost you a extra to engage such professionals but probably save later costs in taxes paid by the estate and provide more structured plans for future generations to preserve wealth.  We can assist you with up to date information about recent changes in the legal requirements of tax structures.  Please call Angela at Extension 112 for an appointment for a Will,  Power of Attorney or Estate Planning.  The first meeting is free and with no obligation to proceed with us. Plan carefully for the next generation.
Share

Wills are necessary. Arrange a Meeting Now

Plan and Prepare for your Estate

You need a Will prepared by a Lawyer

 

 

The Miskin Law Office prepares Wills and Powers of Attorney for individuals in Ontario, Canada. If you live in another jurisdiction your Will should be prepared by a lawyer in that jurisdiction. We draft the Will after a first personal meeting with a lawyer and the client to assess a client’s situation and needs in order to best meet the individual requirements and wishes of the client.  The purpose is to simplify future estate issues to ensure a smooth transition of assets which will reduce the need for future legal services and also plan for reducing taxes payable after death.  We encourage clients to prepare wills that do not lead to family disputes which can ruin relationships and cost a lot of money.  Where there already is an estate dispute we work with clients to resolve the issues sensibly and avoid costly court proceedings.  If there is a dispute mediation is a big part of our services and Murray Miskin conducts mediations and also represent clients in Estate Mediation. Murray Miskin also acts as arbitrator in estate disputes. Estate litigation can be very costly and time consuming and we usually refer complex or unresolvable disputes to lawyers who specialize in such litigation. The best thing is to avoid disputes with properly prepared legal documents. A Will is a document that you can sign with your binding instructions as to who will receive your assets after your death. It names an Estate Trustee (formerly known as Executor) whose responsibility after your death is to manage the estate in accordance with your wishes. You may also propose guardians for your underage children and indicate preferred funeral arrangements in your will. We often prepare specialized wills for people who have children with disabilities or special needs. Until your death the will may be revoked or changed so long as you are mentally competent. Minor changes can be done by Codicils which cost less than a new will. Wills should be redone immediately on a marriage break up. If you do not have a valid will the law determines what happens to your estate without consideration of your preferences.  This may be fine for many families where there are no common law relationships.  If you are living common law or there are children of prior relationships involved it would be wise to obtain legal advice immediately. A Power of Attorney for property is a document you can sign which gives power only in your lifetime over your assets to another person whom you may designate. That authority may be set up to be effective any time or only if you become incapacitated. It may be restricted to dealing with or not dealing with certain matters. You may have more than one person designated so both or either may sign for you. You may name alternates and specify whether the attorney has a right to be paid for what they do. It does not take away your own rights to sign on your own behalf.   A Power of Attorney is a critical document to have should you ever become totally incapacitated or suffer a loss of mental competence.  A Power of Attorney expires on your death.

You may also sign a separate  Power of Attorney for Personal Care where you authorize another person  (again with an alternate) to make health care choices for you when you are unable to do so yourself. This is sometimes called a Living Will. In it you may state your preferences on treatment issues and life support questions.  Many people who want these documents prepared have strong opinions on the possible choices their doctors and family members will have should they become sick to the point where they may have no hope of recovery and may become a burden on others.  Some people do not want their next of kin to decide what to do but instead they may have  a close friend they wish to involve in decisions.  You may also name a doctor or type of doctor you wish to have assess you and give advice when critical decisions must be made.

We strongly emphasize the need to use a lawyer to prepare any of the above document to ensure it is valid and does what you want it to do.  Cheap Will kits are available but pose a serious danger, in that, what you prepare will be invalid unless properly done following strict legal requirements.   For the money you save doing it by yourself it is not worth the risk.  In preparing these documents we always have a lawyer meet with you for as long as necessary to advise you and take careful instructions to make sure the document prepared is what you want it to be. We generally bill and expect full or partial payment by cash, cheque, Interac or credit card at the first meeting.  It is important to have a fully qualified and experienced lawyer discuss your intentions with you to ensure that the will is done properly.  We do not believe it is sufficient to give instructions to a member of the lawyer’s staff in a meeting or by phone.  It is important that the lawyer assess capacity issues at a meeting to prevent future disputes of wills. We sometimes require clients to get a doctor’s note on capacity ahead of signing a will. At a later meeting the documents are signed in accordance with Ontario legal requirements with the lawyer present to oversee, explain the document and discuss any last minute changes.  In cases of complicated wills with unusual provisions or special requirements due to personal circumstances we may charge extra and we will let you know and decide how to proceed at our no cost or obligation meeting in advance of actual will preparation.

Our usual fees (including basic planning for the estate and including disbursements) are set out below with 13% HST added to any fee: Wills: one will $250, a pair for $400
Codicils (Will Changes): fee for one is $100, $150 for a pair
Power of Attorney: one document of each type is $150, a pair of each type are $250

The above fees are discounted when multiple documents are prepared.  Clients pay the fee on a first meeting to discuss wills and then the documents are reviewed and signed on a second visit.  We usually store the original signed Will and give clients 2 copies. For Powers of Attorney we usually make 3 originals and the client keeps 2 and we hold the 3rd. WE ENCOURAGE YOU TO GET YOUR WILL DONE SOON. NOBODY KNOWS WHEN THEIR WILL IS GOING TO BE NEEDED OR WHEN THEY MAY LOSE CAPACITY TO SIGN A WILL OR POWER OF ATTORNEY.

Some clients require personalized estate planning for their special situations. We may recommend that you establish a Trust to deal with your situation.  We may refer you to accountants or other experts to help with planning. This will cost extra but probably save later costs in taxes paid by the estate and provide more structured plans for your family and future generations to preserve wealth.  We can assist you with up to date information about recent changes in tax structures.  Please call and make an appointment for Estate Planning.  The first meeting is free and with no obligation.Plan carefully for the next generation.